* External authors




On the Validity of Arrest as a Proxy for Offense: Race and the Likelihood of Arrest for Violent Crimes

Riccardo Fogliato*

Alice Xiang

Zachary Lipton*

Daniel Nagin*

Alexandra Chouldechova*

* External authors




The risk of re-offense is considered in decision-making at many stages of the criminal justice system, from pre-trial, to sentencing, to parole. To aid decision makers in their assessments, institutions increasingly rely on algorithmic risk assessment instruments (RAIs). These tools assess the likelihood that an individual will be arrested for a new criminal offense within some time window following their release. However, since not all crimes result in arrest, RAIs do not directly assess the risk of re-offense. Furthermore, disparities in the likelihood of arrest can potentially lead to biases in the resulting risk scores. Several recent validations of RAIs have therefore focused on arrests for violent offenses, which are viewed as being more accurate reflections of offending behavior. In this paper, we investigate biases in violent arrest data by analysing racial disparities in the likelihood of arrest for White and Black violent offenders. We focus our study on 2007–2016 incident-level data of violent offenses from 16 US states as recorded in the National Incident Based Reporting System (NIBRS). Our analysis shows that the magnitude and direction of the racial disparities depend on various characteristics of the crimes. In addition, our investigation reveals large variations in arrest rates across geographical locations and offense types. We discuss the implications of the observed disconnect between re-arrest and reoffense in the context of RAIs and the challenges around the use of data from NIBRS to correct for the sampling bias.

Related Publications

Considerations for Ethical Speech Recognition Datasets

WSDM, 2023
Orestis Papakyriakopoulos, Alice Xiang

Speech AI Technologies are largely trained on publicly available datasets or by the massive web-crawling of speech. In both cases, data acquisition focuses on minimizing collection effort, without necessarily taking the data subjects’ protection or user needs into considerat…

Causality for Temporal Unfairness Evaluation and Mitigation

NeurIPS, 2022
Aida Rahmattalabi, Alice Xiang

Recent interests in causality for fair decision-making systems has been accompanied with great skepticism due to practical and epistemological challenges with applying existing causal fairness approaches. Existing works mainly seek to remove the causal effect of social categ…

Men Also Do Laundry: Multi-Attribute Bias Amplification

NeurIPS, 2022
Dora Zhao, Jerone T. A. Andrews, Alice Xiang

As computer vision systems become more widely deployed, there is increasing concern from both the research community and the public that these systems are not only reproducing but amplifying harmful social biases. The phenomenon of bias amplification, which is the focus of t…

  • HOME
  • Publications
  • On the Validity of Arrest as a Proxy for Offense: Race and the Likelihood of Arrest for Violent Crimes


Shape the Future of AI with Sony AI

We want to hear from those of you who have a strong desire
to shape the future of AI.